SMSF trustees who are unable to distinguish between the different tranches of shares they own in one company may face limitations with how the CGT relief can be applied, warns an industry lawyer.
DBA Lawyers director Daniel Butler said where an SMSF trustee has shares in one particular company but increases the amount of shares they own in that company over a period of time, each tranche of shares will have a different cost base.
Where an SMSF trustee is eligible for the CGT relief and wants to apply it they may need to identify between these different tranches of shares, as they may want to elect to apply the relief to some tranches and not others.
“For instance, if you make an election in respect of a share that has a loss, if you were segregated you’d lose that loss,” Mr Butler explained.
“If you’re unsegregated then you don’t lose your loss, but you bring to account a certain amount of the upside. You bring to account the notional capital gain to the extent that you are not exempt under the proportionate CGT transitional relief.”
In Tax Determination TD 33, Mr Butler said the ATO states that where “a disposal of shares occurs and those shares are able to be individually distinguished e.g. by reference to share numbers or other distinctive rights or obligations attached to them, those shares are identifiable; their date of acquisition and cost base will be a matter of fact”.
However, where unidentifiable shares have been disposed of, Mr Butler said the ATO will take a ‘first in, first out’ position.
“So in the absence of identification, the ATO would normally expect a first in, first out position, that is, the ones that were first acquired were the first ones disposed of,” he said.
Taxpayers can only vary this presumption by having accurate and distinct records, he said.
While it may be easy to find information on acquisition dates and cost bases for the 40 per cent of SMSFs that were set up on a real time system that receives data feeds, it may be more difficult for the other 60 per cent of SMSFs.
"For the the 60 per cent of funds that don't have access to this ready data, it will come down to what information is stored. Some accountants don't have sophisticated systems and they may have to go scurrying through old paper records and recompile that accounting system," he said.
SUBSCRIBE TO THE SMSF ADVISER BULLETIN
- 21 Aug 2016Risks flagged with real estate appraisal valuesBy Miranda Brownlee
- 21 Aug 2016Lawyer challenges ATO view on two fund strategiesBy Miranda Brownlee
- 18 Aug 2017ATO locks in details, addresses panic on real-time reportingBy Katarina Taurian
- 18 Aug 2017Data feeds unreliable for new reporting, says mid-tierBy Miranda Brownlee
- 18 Aug 2017Tax component confusion spurs potential tax liabilitiesBy Miranda Brownlee
- 18 Aug 2017Contributions triple in June quarter, survey showsBy Staff Reporter
- view all
- ATO locks in details, addresses panic on real-time reporting
The tax office has addressed several points of confusion with the new events-based reporting regime, locked in key deadlines, and outlined w...read more
- Data feeds unreliable for new reporting, says mid-tier
With an estimated 20 per cent of SMSFs still encountering errors from data feeds, one mid-tier firm believes the ATO should allow SMSF pract...read more
- view all