SMSF lobby group the SMSF Owners' Alliance (SMSFOA) has slammed individuals and groups calling for greater taxation within super, arguing again that an increase could negatively impact the incentive Australians have to save for retirement.
In a statement accompanying its submission to the Tax White Paper, SMSFOA argued that the policy challenge for the government should not be how to extract more tax revenue from superannuation to fix budget problems or to respond to those who claim the current system is unfair.
“Our submission says governments must recognise that by far the largest component of people’s retirement income from super is funded by their own savings and the earnings on their savings,” said SMSFOA executive director Duncan Fairweather.
He argued that while the age pension is important for people on less than average weekly earnings, accumulated earnings on self-funded pensions and the small contribution that tax concessions make are significant for funding super.
“For all income ranges, superannuation tax concessions make up only a small portion of the source of retirement income,” he said.
“The key point here is that the tax incentives should provide the incentive for people to save rather than spend their own money during their working life and so is a much better use of government funds than 100 per cent taxpayer funding of the age pension.”
Despite this, Mr Fairweather said there are three ways in which the earnings on super savings could be improved.
One improvement to the system, according to SMSFOA, could be to strengthen competition and choice among fund managers and investment product providers.
The lobby group is also advocating the simplified operation and administration of super and a reduction in the taxation of superannuation earnings as mentioned in the Henry Report.
The SMSFOA submission called for a ‘TEE’ superannuation system whereby contributions are progressively taxed but earnings and pensions are tax-free.
“Under this TEE system, contributions are included in an individual’s taxable income and thus taxed at progressive income tax rates, with a flat percentage tax rebate,” said Mr Fairweather.
“This system is more effective than the current one at the same cost to the government.”
SMSFOA said that if a structural change to the taxation of superannuation is to be seriously considered as part of the Tax White Paper process, then a closer examination of the benefits of a TEE system is warranted.
“We do not accept that a review of superannuation necessarily implies an increase in taxes on super,” said Mr Fairweather.
“A thorough review should consider improvements that can be tax neutral to the Government.”
SMSFOA sends a clear message to the government, he said.
“If changes are made to superannuation, make sure they lead to a simpler and more efficient superannuation system designed to ensure more Australians are able to and are encouraged to save for their comfortable retirement,” Mr Fairweather said.
SUBSCRIBE TO THE SMSF ADVISER BULLETIN
- 26 Sep 2017ATO set to add new items to SMSF watch listBy Katarina Taurian
- 26 Sep 2017ATO tipped to scrutinise property development and unit trustsBy Jotham Lian
- 26 Sep 2017Statistics reveal full impact of events-based reportingBy Staff Reporter
- 26 Sep 2017Tax advice exemption discrepancy driving away accountantsBy Jotham Lian
- 26 Sep 2017Consultant flags strategies to negate complex ECPI calculationsBy Miranda Brownlee
- 25 Sep 2017Survey results point to major concerns with new reportingBy Miranda Brownlee
- view all
- ATO tipped to scrutinise property development and unit trusts
One big four accounting firm says the ATO has started to zoom in on property development in unit trusts being held in SMSFs and the calculat...read more
- Statistics reveal full impact of events-based reporting
Analysis conducted by SMSF software provider BGL Corporate Solutions has indicated that around 290,000 SMSFs will be affected by the events-...read more
- Tax advice exemption discrepancy driving away accountants
A discrepancy in ASIC’s treatment of licensed and unlicensed accountants in relation to the tax advice exemption instrument is driving acc...read more
- view all