subscribe to our newsletter
subscribe to our newsletter

Keating blasts Hockey’s super proposals

Katarina Taurian
12 March 2015 — 1 minute read

Former prime minister Paul Keating has slammed Treasurer Joe Hockey’s suggestion of opening super to first home buyers, labelling it a “horror story” that could destroy universal retirement savings.

Allowing early access to superannuation would amount to the “wilful destruction” of Australia’s retirement system, Mr Keating told Fairfax Media.

“The key to wealth accumulation in retirement savings is compound earnings. It is the earnings on the earnings plus new weekly capital commitments that allow superannuation accumulations to roughly double every seven to eight years,” he said.


“Such growth in the asset base could not happen if people were permitted to take funds for convenience, thereby diminishing the asset pool and its capacity to compound.

“This would especially be the case for younger home buyers who would typically have a relatively modest pool of superannuation savings from which to draw.”

As reported earlier this week, the superannuation industry has also hit back at Mr Hockey’s suggestions.

The SMSF Association’s Graeme Colley questioned whether first home buyers would have a substantial enough home deposit in the super fund, while the Association of Superannuation Funds of Australia’s chief executive Pauline Vamos said the move would largely benefit high-income earners.

“Pumping another source of funds into an already overheated property market only benefits those selling properties,” added Quantum Financial principal Tim Mackay.

“How on earth will [the] resulting increased house prices benefit younger people? Politicians sharing their thought bubbles in super does nothing for consumers’ confidence in the super system,” he told SMSF Adviser.

Keating blasts Hockey’s super proposals
smsf logo
smsfadviser logo
join the discussion

Why we’ll keep delivering for our communities in the face of COVID-19


As Australia tries to keep pace with a rapidly changing business and social landscape in the wake of COVID-19, Momentum Media is leading the way delivering essential content to our communities, writes Alex Whitlock, director of SMSF Adviser.

Read more

Latest poll

Do you outsource a part of your business operations?

Website Notifications

Get notifications in real-time for staying up to date with content that matters to you.