The SMSF Professionals’ Association of Australia (SPAA) has called for more “appropriate” methodologies to be used when measuring superannuation tax concessions, claiming the current system is “fatally flawed.”
Measuring the concessions as tax expenditure using a comprehensive income benchmark is “misleading and biased” against concessions, said SPAA chief executive officer Andrea Slattery.
“[This is because] any derivation from income being taxed at a taxpayer’s marginal tax rate is regarded as a cost to government revenue,” she said.
Ms Slattery added that while the current methodology is “theoretically correct” under a comprehensive income benchmark, it doesn’t include factors such as future government savings from reduced spending on the age pension.
“SPAA believes this skews the debate regarding the level of concessions and the appropriateness of concessional taxation of superannuation contributions as an incentive for people to save for their retirement,” she said.
The association recommends that an expenditure tax benchmark be used to estimate the cost of the superannuation tax concessions.
“It would be more appropriate for estimating tax concessions as an expenditure tax benchmark [and] has a more appropriate focus on the provision and taxation of superannuation benefits rather than the tax forgone for the concessions,” Ms Slattery said.
SPAA’s director of technical and professional standards, Graeme Colley, told SMSF Adviser the association is concerned about the adequacy of the population’s superannuation savings.
“[We] just don’t think the incentives there are good enough to enable people to have enough for retirement,” Mr Colley said.
SPAA regularly consults with the government and the Australian Taxation Office to discuss policy and the effect it will have on Australians, he added.
“We represent a third of the money within superannuation and the current government recognises that and consults with us quite regularly,” he said.
SUBSCRIBE TO THE SMSF ADVISER BULLETIN
- 21 Aug 2016Risks flagged with real estate appraisal valuesBy Miranda Brownlee
- 21 Aug 2016Lawyer challenges ATO view on two fund strategiesBy Miranda Brownlee
- 18 Aug 2017ATO locks in details, addresses panic on real-time reportingBy Katarina Taurian
- 18 Aug 2017Data feeds unreliable for new reporting, says mid-tierBy Miranda Brownlee
- 18 Aug 2017Tax component confusion spurs potential tax liabilitiesBy Miranda Brownlee
- 18 Aug 2017Contributions triple in June quarter, survey showsBy Staff Reporter
- view all
- ATO locks in details, addresses panic on real-time reporting
The tax office has addressed several points of confusion with the new events-based reporting regime, locked in key deadlines, and outlined w...read more
- Data feeds unreliable for new reporting, says mid-tier
With an estimated 20 per cent of SMSFs still encountering errors from data feeds, one mid-tier firm believes the ATO should allow SMSF pract...read more
- view all