As part of the 2014/2015 federal Budget, the government has moved to introduce a mechanism to allow taxpayers to withdraw excess non-concessional contributions made after 1 July 2013.
Speaking to SMSF Adviser, HLB Mann Judd director of superannuation Andrew Yee said the “contentious” issue is going to be administering this new system and calculating the earnings on the excess non-concessional contributions.
“Auditors of SMSFs need to determine if that figure is correct or not and if it is within the law. It is up to the trustee to check those earnings, but the auditor needs to check that figure,” he said.
“Unless there is a certain formula it is going to be quite arbitrary [and] unless there are some sort of guidelines on this calculation and some rules on this new law, then it will be difficult for the auditor… and could cause problems down the track,” he said.
“If trustees deliberately put in excess contributions knowing that they just have to take out their capital later on, the earnings is a figure that can maybe be manipulated or mistakenly gotten wrong, and that is an issue,” he added.
Mr Yee said that if money goes into an SMSF which is deemed excess, from the time that money entered the fund it has earned income from interest, dividends or rent.
“That income has to be now taken out and included as personal taxable income, subject to marginal tax rate, and then the issue is how do we calculate that magical number of income?” he said.
This is merely a miniscule subset of the larger unit pricing & credit pricing issue, which robust risk management must address in any fund. Such calculations arise at entry, internal switching, rollovers and benefit payments. If auditors find it a problem, consult an actuary!