A parliamentary committee has recommended that Treasury analyse the true costs and benefits of superannuation tax concessions.
Yesterday, the House of Representatives Tax and Revenue Committee delivered its report on how the annual Tax Expenditures Statement (TES) should be calculated.
The committee noted that superannuation can have significant long-term benefits but these are not taken into account by Treasury in the TES.
“The Committee believes that the Statement (TES), in its current form, produces figures on the current costs of superannuation tax concessions without any reflection or analysis about future benefits either to the Government or to retirees. If one of the purposes of the Statement is to inform debate, then the Committee believes that it is paramount that the Statement and related policy analysis should do so in a balanced way,” the committee said.
This argument is consistent with industry views that there needs to be a more holistic and sophisticated approach to valuing tax concessions, with a model that, for example, factors in a reduction in age pension costs.
The SMSF Owners’ Alliance (SMSFOA) has welcomed the recommendation, believing there is a need for a more “balanced” view of superannuation tax concessions.
“[This recommendation] should lead to a more objective policy debate over the economic value of superannuation. This debate is often distorted by media reports and policy papers focusing on the apparent cost of superannuation tax concessions,” SMSFOA stated.
“It is to be hoped the Committee’s report will put an end to alarming headlines proclaiming the $32 billion (and more) cost of superannuation tax concessions, implying that this revenue could be saved if superannuation tax concessions are removed,” SMSFOA said.
SUBSCRIBE TO THE SMSF ADVISER BULLETIN
- 21 Aug 2016Risks flagged with real estate appraisal valuesBy Miranda Brownlee
- 21 Aug 2016Lawyer challenges ATO view on two fund strategiesBy Miranda Brownlee
- 18 Aug 2017ATO locks in details, addresses panic on real-time reportingBy Katarina Taurian
- 18 Aug 2017Data feeds unreliable for new reporting, says mid-tierBy Miranda Brownlee
- 18 Aug 2017Tax component confusion spurs potential tax liabilitiesBy Miranda Brownlee
- 18 Aug 2017Contributions triple in June quarter, survey showsBy Staff Reporter
- view all
- ATO locks in details, addresses panic on real-time reporting
The tax office has addressed several points of confusion with the new events-based reporting regime, locked in key deadlines, and outlined w...read more
- Data feeds unreliable for new reporting, says mid-tier
With an estimated 20 per cent of SMSFs still encountering errors from data feeds, one mid-tier firm believes the ATO should allow SMSF pract...read more
- view all