As criticism for Treasurer Joe Hockey’s proposal to open super to first home buyers mounts, one property analyst has warned the move would “artificially inflate” demand for property.
As reported last week, Mr Hockey said he is concerned about the difficult position faced by first home buyers and that Australians “need to have these conversations” about making super more flexible.
This has been met with strong disproval from the superannuation industry and recently communications minister Malcolm Turnbull labelled the proposal a “thoroughly bad idea”.
SQM Research managing director Louis Christopher believes Mr Hockey’s idea would “promote a property bubble” if ever adopted.
“The problem is that tinkering with the property market in this way would only serve to artificially inflate demand for property and therefore push up house prices even higher than they are now,” he said.
Mr Christopher said such a policy would “have a similar distortionary effect” to the first home owner grant, which he said caused prices to rise in excess of the handouts.
He also said that Mr Hockey’s super idea would be impractical for most first home buyers in their twenties and thirties.
“With Sydney vendors now asking for over $1 million for a house, a 10 per cent deposit on a Sydney home raised through super would erode almost entirely the retirement savings of most people in that age group,” he said.
Mr Christopher said the way to make housing more affordable is not to increase, but reduce government intervention – starting with negative gearing.
“Reducing negative gearing, a highly distortionary policy, would have a far more beneficial effect on promoting housing affordability,” he said.
“If negative gearing was repealed or altered, investors who are now gobbling up property would back off buying houses, which is what those who are demanding lower dwelling prices want to see.”
SUBSCRIBE TO THE SMSF ADVISER BULLETIN
28 Jun 2016Class releases CGT relief applications in softwareBy Staff Reporter
28 Jun 2016Former ATO exec departs consultancy firmBy Miranda Brownlee
28 Jun 2016Major bank tightens lending policies for SMSF loansBy Staff Reporter
27 Jun 2017SMSF services provider to acquire mid-tier licenseeBy Staff Reporter
28 Jun 2016Big dealer groups tipped to exit limited licensingBy Miranda Brownlee
27 Jun 2017Technical expert clarifies CGT relief requirements for TRISsBy Miranda Brownlee
- view all
Class releases CGT relief applications in software
In preparation for the super reforms commencing on Saturday, Class has released a software update that includes CGT relief applications and ...read more
Major bank tightens lending policies for SMSF loans
One of the big four banks has announced changes to its SMSF loans which will see the maximum interest-only repayment term halved and a $200,...read more
SMSF services provider to acquire mid-tier licensee
A financial services company is set to acquire a mid-tier financial advice licensee that provides limited licensing to accountants. ...read more
- view all